loader image

Black Box by Unrivaled: Catholic Guilt, Existential Dread and the Joy of Turning Everything Up to Eleven

Dying. Divinity. Angst. That unthinkable thought that maybe, just maybe, there’s no god, no ghost, no afterlife at all waiting for you on the other side of the grave. Not exactly what’s running on the stereo in the background of your average frothy afternoon, but Cincinnati’s long-running emo rockers, Unrivaled have never been one to let convention lead the way. Their 2026 sophomore record, Black Box, is an emo rock opera on life, death and the great mysteries thereof, told with an almost dogged DIY mentality that’s borderline offbeat.

And in some ways, it’s quite fitting: if you’re going to spend an album questioning the state of this universe, at least do so at the top of your lungs.

Since their start in 2019, Unrivaled has been exploring a sound that is the blending of punk, alt-rock and metal. Taking the powerhouse guitar work of bands like Iron Maiden and Avenged Sevenfold and injecting the melodic despair of bands like Rise Against, Sum 41 and My Chemical Romance. It’s an eclectic blend of classic metal’s theatrical flair and the angsty melodies of bands from the early 2000s emo era. Basically, you’re gonna be as likely to get a guitar solo and an emotional breakdown. Hopefully at the same time.

Credit: Photo by Batt Kilbarger

Black Box is so close to 37 minutes that it certainly can’t require you to sacrifice an entire weekend. The 12 songs on the record oscillate between heavy alternative rock, pugnacious punk and emo lyricism for what is a fairly forward-facing record. And four songs in particular highlight the record’s emotional concerns in a way that’s more laser-beam than spotlight.

Call Me Liar might just be the most interesting emotional place to start the album. Rather than another boring “I’m so sad” song, this one gets into the self-doubt and low self-esteem that can slowly eat away at a person’s sense of self. It’s so brutally honest; honest about the failure, the sadness and the anger that drives the song. And the compelling thing about it is that the song’s strength isn’t necessarily in its comforting qualities; more so its ability to make you hear the pain. Think My Chemical Romance in their little confessional state, but with a more punk-rock attitude like Rise Against.  

DVR (Hey Mister) reaches far darker depths of this emotional discomfort. Frustration, emotional exhaustion and the ever more ominous sensation of losing control drive the track – with its lyrics bouncing between screams for honesty, references to drugs and an ongoing request for some closure. There’s an awkwardness to this, the lament to a potential savior who can set things to rights which sounds eerily similar to the more miserable narrative styles of early 2000s emo and alt-punk. The effect is that much more uncomfortable because this isn’t a feeling that will be completely fixed by the last chorus; sometimes you just need to ask them to stop making everything worse.  

Presumed Dead could possibly be the most direct exploration of this, confronting mortality using the vivid imagery. Lyrically it provides its listeners with images of suffocation, being enclosed, the terrifying prospect of being buried alive whilst asking if anyone can hear him. It is a bold way to present our existential anxiety: not something that we ponder from a distance but an imminent, horrible fate. It certainly influences the emotional high stakes of My Chemical Romance’s overblown songwriting, but this has the integrity and sound of something closer to pop-punk and alt-rock that hits harder and is definitely not for the faint of heart.

Promise subverts this instinct to a fear of death and instead reduces it into a desperate plea for assurance. One of the most disturbing features of this section is that it poses the possibility of the singer’s otherworldliness by asking “would you believe that I am already dead?” The lyrics become a repetition of the need for someone to maintain order whilst the world unravels. This arguably has the most emotionally naked connotations of any section of the record, as it tries to do so whilst dealing with the cold realities of existence. It has an approachable melodic quality that will have a lot of people listening from Rise Against fans to the more soppy side of alternative music.

At the end of the day, this is an ambitious foray into more serious musical territory from a band that has been honing its act for a few years. Everything from the punk/metal/emo sounds to the character-driven themes of Catholic guilt, death and existential angst is ultimately rooted in one musical and conceptual place.  

“Black Box” might not provide all the answers to life’s great mysteries or unravel the enigma of death in 37 minutes. Sometimes there is no need for a spiritual awakening. Sometimes there’s no time for a philosophical revolution. Sometimes you just need a really loud guitar and some baggage to go with it and if there’s no one waiting on the other side, at least we had a modern rock opera to soundtrack us there.

Follow Unrivaled

Promoted Content

About the Author

Share this article