loader image

DownTown Mystic Brings the Old Magic of Rock ’n’ Roll to Life on “Maybe Love’s a Crime”

You can dismiss the song before you’ve heard it as another nostalgic trip, or you can find out if the artist can convince you the old machine is still working. Maybe Love’s A Crime by Down Town Mystic sits somewhere in the middle of the two camps, and I mean that as a compliment.

DownTown Mystic is the brainchild of American rocker Robert Allen, who has a somewhat unique take on what really should be considered rock music: vintage guitars, old-school recording, harmonies, storytelling and a bit of swing to separate rock ‘n’ roll from the equally blurry “Rock,” a term that, by his logic, is applied to everything bigger than a bedroom acoustic rehearsal.

Credit: Mark Maryanovich Photography

Maybe Love’s A Crime comes close to that sentiment. Its core is a Dion-sounding shuffle, possessing the unpretentious, rambling groove of ’60s-era rock yet not feeling like someone has unearthed an ancient record, blown off the dust and pressed play.

That shuffle is, essentially, the song’s motor. Instead of pumping through distortion or just turning everything way up, the song derives its power through groove. The piano, electric Rhodes and guitars fill out the arrangement and add some dimension, but they are not showboating. You can feel that somewhere in the performance. It doesn’t feel like it was carefully and precisely constructed in a studio and then cleaned up to perfection. It does have a bit of a loose feeling to it, but that actually works because the musicians really do get the groove. 

Allen’s larger scope of musical reference points is equally recognizable: Tom Petty, Bruce Springsteen, Buffalo Springfield, Rockpile, the entire span of Americana and roots-rock. None of that is highbrow obscurity, but the genius of DownTown Mystic is how comfortably he can stay within those parameters while blending musical styles instead of wowing audiences with a history lesson.

That also gives Maybe Love’s A Crime a healthy sense of identity. It doesn’t have a desire to be today’s rock with a phony modern sound. It is more contemporary in its recording quality and performance assurance than it is trendy in its adoption of whatever production magic is in fashion.

That is also kind of refreshing. Maybe Love’s A Crime seems content not to attempt to reinvent the wheel as far as rock music goes. It appears to want the groove, the guitars, the shuffle and the band-playing-in-a-room feeling. The old classics still work. You’ve just gotta finesse ’em.

Follow DownTown Mystic

Promoted Content

About the Author

Share this article